Cardano DReps reject Toto Finance's 22M ADA Strategic Copper Reserve proposal

Editorial illustration: A dark blue vault bearing the Cardano symbol stands beside a closed metal gate, with copper ingots stacked on the other side.

In brief

  • Cardano DReps rejected Toto Finance's 22 million ADA Strategic Copper Reserve proposal; the vote closed Nov. 15.
  • DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA voted against; those holding 20.02 million ADA voted in favor.
  • Cardano Foundation voted no, citing a fee-heavy commodity position without safeguards in place.
  • DRep John MacPherson said the treasury would carry both copper and ADA price risk.

What Toto Finance proposed

Toto Finance, a company led by Monty Metzger, submitted the proposal on Oct. 15. The plan was to buy copper with 14.72 million ADA and store it in a warehouse near New Orleans. Toto Finance would then issue one CuTT token for each pound of copper (a tokenized real-world asset backed by physical metal), and the copper would be sold within 18 to 24 months.

The request is also worth less than it was. ADA traded at $0.152 on Monday, which put the 22 million ADA at around $3.3 million, according to U.Today.

Why the big voters said no

The Cardano Foundation votes as a DRep, and it announced its "No" vote back in October. It explained its reasoning in a statement:

"We recognize the opportunity in real-world asset tokenization; however, this proposal places 22,000,000 ada under the recipient's sole control to fund a fee-heavy concentrated commodity position whose safeguards are not yet in place,"

DRep John MacPherson also voted "No" and explained his decision in a post on X. He wrote that he isn't against real-world assets on Cardano. His objection was that the proposal asked the treasury to take on copper price risk and ADA price risk at the same time. He also said Toto Finance would collect up to about 3.4 million ADA in fees under the plan. MacPherson did give Toto Finance some credit, though. He said the proposal was more honest about its risks than most.

The Constitutional Committee didn't back it either.

Three committee members voted "No," and the other four didn't vote.

The double exposure problem

Crypto commentator Ingeniero Cripto made a similar point. In his view, the key problem was the double exposure to copper and ADA prices, since the Cardano treasury already holds ADA. He said RWAs on Cardano make sense, but that funding the asset itself is a different question from funding the rails.

None of the critics quoted here said tokenized commodities don't belong on Cardano. Their objection was to the structure: treasury funds would buy the commodity directly, and one recipient would control the money.

Frequently asked questions

What was Toto Finance's Strategic Copper Reserve proposal?

Toto Finance, led by Monty Metzger, asked for 22 million ADA from the Cardano treasury. It planned to buy copper with 14.72 million ADA, store it in a warehouse near New Orleans and issue one CuTT token per pound. The copper would be sold within 18 to 24 months.

How did Cardano DReps vote on the copper reserve proposal?

The vote closed on Nov. 15. According to Cardano governance data reported by U.Today, DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA voted against the proposal and DReps holding 20.02 million ADA voted for it. Three Constitutional Committee members voted no, and the other four did not vote.

Why did critics oppose the Cardano copper reserve?

DRep John MacPherson said the treasury would take on both copper and ADA price risk, and commentator Ingeniero Cripto called this double exposure the key problem. The Cardano Foundation said the plan put 22 million ADA under the recipient's sole control to fund a fee-heavy commodity position without safeguards in place.