CFTC sues Louisiana over order restricting Kalshi, Coinbase prediction markets

Editorial illustration: A red Louisiana silhouette stands behind a striped barrier beside gold justice scales. Cream tiles bearing a green check and an orange cross sit in the foreground.

In brief

  • Louisiana obtained an ex parte restraining order on Nov. 12, according to the CFTC's complaint.
  • The order names Robinhood Derivatives, Coinbase Financial Markets, Kalshi entities, ForecastEx and Rothera.
  • The CFTC and the US sued Louisiana on Nov. 13, arguing federal derivatives law preempts state enforcement.
  • Robinhood reported $173 million in quarterly event-contract revenue; Coinbase reported over $200 million annualized.
  • The order's effect on customer positions, settlement and withdrawals remains unconfirmed.

What the order covers

The CFTC's complaint quotes restrictions on offering, clearing, settling, brokering and otherwise facilitating specified event contracts involving people located in Louisiana without the required state license and permit. That's a wide net. It reaches brokers and clearinghouses as well as exchanges, and the complaint's description of the statutory scope includes sports, elections and award events. Because the order was obtained ex parte, the other side wasn't heard first.

The distribution chain matters here. Robinhood's product disclosure identifies Robinhood Derivatives as the intermediary and lists KalshiEX, ForecastEx, Rothera and Crypto.com Derivatives North America as venues, while Coinbase says it offers its prediction contracts through Coinbase Financial Markets and has Kalshi operate them. CryptoSlate's analysis says that if the same restricted broker stays involved, moving a contract to another venue leaves the intermediary within the order's documented reach (a conditional legal reading, not a confirmed outcome).

Revenue on the line

Robinhood and Coinbase both report prediction-market revenue alongside their crypto businesses. Robinhood reported $173 million in event-contract revenue for the quarter ended Sept. 30, more than six times the year-earlier figure. Its cryptocurrency revenue for the same quarter was $120 million, down 55%.

Coinbase said on Oct. 29 that its prediction markets had surpassed $200 million in annualized revenue. One figure's quarterly and the other's annualized, so they don't combine into a single number.

Where the litigation stands

The federal suit seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, including a bar on enforcing or extending the state order. The government's motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction was listed for submission on Nov. 17. In Louisiana's own enforcement case, which moved to federal court, Robinhood is seeking to vacate the state order and Rothera is seeking its dissolution or modification.

These are arguments in pending litigation, not rulings.

What it means for customers isn't clear yet. How the order affects new orders, existing positions, settlement and withdrawals remains unconfirmed, and so does each company's implementation.

Frequently asked questions

Which companies does Louisiana's prediction-market order name?

The court-filed copy of the order names Robinhood Derivatives, Coinbase Financial Markets, multiple Kalshi entities, ForecastEx and Rothera. According to the CFTC's complaint, the order was obtained ex parte on Nov. 12 against registered exchanges, futures commission merchants and derivatives clearing organizations.

Why did the CFTC sue Louisiana?

The US and the CFTC sued Louisiana and state officials on Nov. 13, arguing that federal derivatives law preempts the state's enforcement. They seek declaratory and injunctive relief, including a bar on enforcing or extending the state order. Their motion for a restraining order and preliminary injunction was listed for submission on Nov. 17.