Judge acquits Peraire-Bueno brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV fraud case

Editorial illustration: Open metal handcuffs lie in front of a glowing purple Ethereum symbol, with a wooden judge’s gavel and sound block behind them.

In brief

  • Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges.
  • Prosecutors alleged the brothers took $25 million from Ethereum trading bots in about 12 seconds.
  • Clarke found the transactions didn't amount to false promises or criminal fraud.
  • The ruling didn't decide whether the conduct was ethical or broke other laws.

What prosecutors alleged

Prosecutors alleged that the MIT-educated brothers exploited a flaw in maximal extractable value (MEV)-boost software in April 2023. The government's theory was that they lured sandwich-trading bots into transactions, then disrupted them. Prosecutors said the brothers secured $25 million in about 12 seconds.

Those were allegations, and they didn't hold up as fraud.

Why Clarke ruled the way she did

Clarke said the transactions didn't amount to false promises or criminal fraud. That's the heart of it. Per Cointelegraph, the ruling turned on whether prosecutors could prove the brothers made material misrepresentations, and Clarke found they hadn't.

The ruling also cited a 2025 decision involving Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg, in which a judge found insufficient evidence of false representations.

There's a caveat, though (and Clarke was explicit about it). She said the case wasn't about whether the brothers' actions were ethical or may have violated other laws. The acquittal settles the fraud charges. It doesn't settle the ethics question.

This wasn't the case's first trip through the courts. The brothers' first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after jurors failed to reach a verdict, Cointelegraph reported.

Coin Center calls it "excellent news"

Coin Center executive director Peter Van Valkenburgh called the acquittal "excellent news." He said prosecutors' "honest validator" theory risked letting the government use wire fraud laws to impose its own standards of conduct on Ethereum validators.

“Anyone participating in an open network would have to wonder whether prosecutors might later declare their behavior ‘dishonest’ and haul them into court,” Valkenburgh said

That's the worry for people running validators on an open network like Ethereum. The ruling answers the fraud question for these two defendants, but Clarke said plainly that it doesn't answer whether what they did was ethical or broke some other law.

Frequently asked questions

Why did the judge acquit the Peraire-Bueno brothers?

Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that prosecutors failed to prove the brothers made material misrepresentations. She said the transactions did not amount to false promises or criminal fraud, according to Cointelegraph.

Did the ruling say the brothers' conduct was ethical?

No. Clarke said the case was not about whether the brothers' actions were ethical or may have violated other laws. The acquittal covers the wire fraud and related charges only.

What did prosecutors allege the brothers did?

Prosecutors alleged the brothers exploited a flaw in MEV-boost software in April 2023, luring sandwich-trading bots into transactions and then disrupting them. They alleged the brothers secured $25 million in about 12 seconds.