Peraire-Bueno acquittal leaves BlackRock ETF's MEV risk open, Cointelegraph says
In brief
- BlackRock's staked Ether ETF earns a share of what traders pay for Ethereum transaction priority.
- BlackRock's prospectus flagged the Peraire-Bueno prosecution because of that income.
- The Peraire-Bueno acquittal turned on a narrower question than trade-ordering profits, Cointelegraph says.
- Prosecutors couldn't establish what terms the brothers accepted from the service that sent the block.
Why BlackRock flagged the case
The income is the link here. According to Cointelegraph's analysis by Adrian Zmudzinski, BlackRock's staked Ether ETF takes a cut of what traders pay for priority on Ethereum, and that's why the firm flagged the prosecution of the Peraire-Bueno brothers in its prospectus.
The warning itself was simple. If profiting from the order of trades were found unlawful, BlackRock said its staking program could be disrupted (per Cointelegraph's description of the prospectus).
The brothers were acquitted, according to Cointelegraph.
What prosecutors had to prove
The amount at issue was about $25 million, lost by three traders when trades ran in a different order from the one the brothers' validator had signed. To prove fraud, prosecutors had to show that signing the proposed block amounted to a promise to publish the trades in that order.
They couldn't establish what terms the brothers had accepted from the service that sent them the block, Cointelegraph reported. That's a narrow point, and it's the one the outlet says decided the case. In its reading, the fraud case turned on that narrower question, so the acquittal left the legal risk to BlackRock's trade-ordering income unresolved.
The Coinbase commitment
BlackRock's own staking agreement spells out validator duties in at least one area, according to Cointelegraph's reading of the agreement. When the fund wants validators to maintain controls for screening sanctioned wallets, Coinbase must get a binding commitment from them. If a validator breaks that commitment, the fund can point to a duty the validator accepted and ask Coinbase to enforce it.
That's the kind of accepted term the prosecution couldn't pin down in the Peraire-Bueno case, where nobody could show what the validator had actually agreed to. For an ETF that earns from how Ethereum orders its transactions, Cointelegraph's argument is that the criminal case didn't answer the question BlackRock put in its prospectus.
Frequently asked questions
Why did BlackRock flag the Peraire-Bueno prosecution in its ETF prospectus?
BlackRock's staked Ether ETF earns a share of what traders pay to get one Ethereum transaction ahead of another. According to Cointelegraph, the firm warned that its staking program could be disrupted if profiting from the order of trades were found unlawful, so it flagged the case.
What did prosecutors need to prove in the $25 million Ethereum case?
Prosecutors had to show that signing the proposed block amounted to a promise to publish the trades in that order. Cointelegraph reported they couldn't establish what terms the brothers had accepted from the service that sent them the block. The brothers were acquitted, according to Cointelegraph.
How does BlackRock's staking agreement bind validators?
According to Cointelegraph, when the fund wants validators to maintain controls for screening sanctioned wallets, Coinbase must get a binding commitment from them. If a validator breaks that commitment, the fund can point to a duty the validator accepted and ask Coinbase to enforce it.


